Saturday, November 06, 2010

Greatest Health Care System in the World?


Maybe for John Boehner. But he's well covered (and not just with Ban de Soleil Mega Tan) by the federal government. But what about the rest of us? Those of us who are too lazy or stupid to pull ourselves up by our bootstraps and become congressmen. I suppose that if number one means the freedom to go bankrupt because of medical bills, we fit that bill. USA! USA! But, really, by what metric are we number one? How do we compare with the rest of the western democracies? For the sake of clarity I'll limit the comparison to prosperous western democracies, the ones that supply health care to all their citizens.Unless you live in Texas or Mississippi it is hardly fair to compare our circumstances with the Republic of Congo. Lets take a tour -

Average life expectancy (from our friends at the CIA) :
1 Monaco
89.78
2010 est.
2 Macau
84.38
2010 est.
3 San Marino
82.95
2010 est.
4 Andorra
82.36
2010 est.
5 Japan
82.17
2010 est.
6 Guernsey
82.08
2010 est.
7 Singapore
82.06
2010 est.
8 Hong Kong
81.96
2010 est.
9 Australia
81.72
2010 est.
10 Canada
81.29
2010 est.
11 Jersey
81.28
2010 est.
12 France
81.09
2010 est.
13 Spain
81.07
2010 est.
14 Sweden
80.97
2010 est.
15 Switzerland
80.97
2010 est.
16 Israel
80.86
2010 est.
17 Iceland
80.79
2010 est.
18 Anguilla
80.77
2010 est.
19 Bermuda
80.60
2010 est.
20 Cayman Islands
80.57
2010 est.
21 Isle of Man
80.53
2010 est.
22 New Zealand
80.48
2010 est.
23 Italy
80.33
2010 est.
24 Liechtenstein
80.19
2010 est.
25 Norway
80.08
2010 est.
26 Ireland
80.07
2010 est.
27 Jordan
79.92
2010 est.
28 United Kingdom
79.92
2010 est.
29 Greece
79.80
2010 est.
30 Saint Pierre and Miquelon
79.74
2010 est.
31 Austria
79.65
2010 est.
32 Malta
79.59
2010 est.
33 Faroe Islands
79.58
2010 est.
34 Netherlands
79.55
2010 est.
35 Luxembourg
79.48
2010 est.
36 Germany
79.41
2010 est.
37 Belgium
79.37
2010 est.
38 Virgin Islands
79.19
2010 est.
39 Finland
79.13
2010 est.
40 Wallis and Futuna
78.83
2010 est.
41 European Union
78.82
2010 est.
42 Korea, South
78.81
2010 est.
43 Puerto Rico
78.77
2010 est.
44 Bosnia and Herzegovina
78.66
2010 est.
45 Saint Helena, Ascension, and Tristan da Cunha
78.60
2010 est.
46 Gibraltar
78.53
2010 est.
47 Denmark
78.47
2010 est.
48 Portugal
78.38
2010 est.
49 United States
78.24
2010 est.
50 Taiwan
78.15
2010 est.

OK. Top 50 isn't too bad. At least we beat Taiwan. And there is no indication that this is healthcare related, even though those countries that beat us have some version of Obamacare - only better. It may well be lifestyle. Compare a bunch of fish eaters to us Twinkie soaked Americans? - no fair!

If by best Speaker Boehner means most expensive he may well have a point-
  Per Capita health expenditures in US dollars:
Iceland - $3294
Australia- $3123
Canada- $3173
France - $3040
United Kingdom -$2560
Japan - $2293
United States - $6096
Yay! Numero Uno! We get to spend twice as much as those countries listed above and still manage to rank below them in average life expectancy. Maybe Boehner meant something else. Maybe he meant that, despite all evidence to the contrary, we think we have the best health care system in the world. Let's see - (from Fox news, no less)

Here's someone who's already laid it all out (I could have saved myself the trouble):
Percent of people who believe their health care system needs fundamental  change:
United States   60%
Sweden          58
United Kingdom  52
Japan           47
Netherlands     46
France          42
Canada          38
We won again. To recap - the United States has the best health care system if you are a wealthy Republican congressman. Or an Insurance executive. Or maybe a plastic surgeon. Basically Boehner is full of shit. But you knew that already. Boehner is afraid, and rightly so, that once the American people find out the benefits of the incremental changes in the admittedly flawed Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act   they will come to view  universal health care as a fundamental right in a prosperous and civilized society.  Boehner and the Republican party has never gotten over the fact that Social Security and Medicare are popular and irreversible accomplishments of American progressives. Just like Boehner can't get over the tan tax.




No comments:

Post a Comment